Strategic Supply & Marketing Agreements as Complementary Alternative to Classic Contract Manufacturing

Life Science Leader , September 2014

The combination of increased government healthcare coverage, ballooning government debt, and massive expiry of patent protection on originator drugs has spurred an interest in sourcing generic active pharmaceutical ingredients and finished drugs from lower-cost countries.

In this context, India has emerged as a powerhouse in supplying the Western pharmaceutical markets. India now ranks second to U.S. only in terms of FDA-inspected facilities and number of active DMFs (drug master files), and it provides great value for a relatively secure supply of pharmaceuticals.

U.S. based pharmaceutical companies now have numerous strategic supply and marketing agreements in place with the Indian pharma industry. Allergan and Pfizer with Nicholas Piramal, Wyeth with Bharat Biotech, and DSM with Lupin are examples of such strategic collaborations.
 
These strategic supply and marketing partnerships extract maximum value for their shareholders as they maximize capacity utilization in India and market share in the U.S. at minimum incremental expense. No up-front capital investment, lower manufacturing variable, and fixed costs in combination with higher sales volumes/prices are all powerful drivers in setting up these strategic agreements. This relationship, in fact, has obvious similarities with formal contract manufacturing arrangements. Nevertheless, due to the lack of transparency in these supply and marketing arrangements, the outcomes are not generally included in the contract manufacturing industry landscape.

Strategic supply and marketing agreements can produce spectacular results for Indian manufacturers and American sellers alike.

Nice Insight market research shows now that this “shadow” contract manufacturing industry has been increasing spectacularly over the last five years and is expected to continue to provide great opportunities for both Indian and U.S. parties.

For example, Lupin has a strategic supply and marketing collaboration with DSM in the field of cephalosporines. Figure 1 shows that Lupin’s number of shipments for four cephalosporine products will nearly triple by the end of 2014 when compared to 2009.
Wockhardt, another major name in the Indian pharma landscape, had a similar strategic agreement with U.S.-based Ivax* for anti-ulcer drugs.
 
Figure 2 shows a comparative view of Wockhardt’s Q2 shipments to the U.S. for famotidine, lansoprazole, and ranitidine. The cumulative profile of the graph suggests that Wockhardt has quadrupled its shipments of anti-ulcer drugs to the U.S. between 2009 and 2013.

lsl_chart_0914.jpg

Dishman offers yet another example of synergies between American and Indian contract manufacturing companies. According to the company website, Dishman’s focus is on high-value, cost-competitive contract services including process development, process optimization, manufacture for late-stage clinical and commercial supplies of prescription and over the counter drugs.
 
Dishman is a leader in the ammonium salts for food and drug use such as cetylpyridinium chloride(CPC). CPC is a bactericide used in OTC mouthwash, lozenges, and cough syrups. By way of example, CPC is used in the formulation of branded products such as Listerine (J&J), Crest (P&G), Colgate (Colgate Oral Pharmaceuticals), and ACT (Chattem). It is also used in a range of other no-name products sold by chains such as CVS, Walgreens, Target, and Wal-Mart. Dishman’s expertise in highly-regulated manufacturing of quaternary ammonium salts in combination with the marketing power of P&G, for example, makes good business sense.
 
Figure 3 shows the number of annual quaternary ammonium salt shipments to U.S. made by Dishman, including cetylpyridinium chloride. While the business displays considerable year-over-year volatility, the linear trend line clearly shows that Dishman’s business has roughly doubled between 2009 and 2014. In fact, if Dishman shipments continue at the same pace in the second half of this year, 2014 will be a record year for the company’s quaternary ammonium salt business.
 
In conclusion, our research clearly shows that strategic supply and marketing agreements can produce spectacular results for Indian manufacturers and American sellers alike. There is little market research publically available in the “shadow” contract manufacturing industry. Nice Insight research is now shedding some preliminary light in the spectacular growth rate of this market segment.
 
* Ivax was acquired by Teva in 2013 therefore data is available only to the end of Q2/2013.

 

Nice Insight

Nice Insight, established in 2010, is the research division of That’s Nice, A Science Agency, providing data and analysis from proprietary annual surveys, custom primary qualitative and quantitative research as well as extensive secondary research. Current annual surveys include The Nice Insight Contract Development & Manufacturing (CDMO/CMO), Survey The Nice Insight Contract Research - Preclinical and Clinical (CRO) Survey, The Nice Insight Pharmaceutical Equipment Survey, and The Nice Insight Pharmaceutical Excipients Survey.

Q: